Few things are more frustrating than weight gain that doesn’t match your behavior. You can accept gaining weight after months of indulgence — that makes sense. But gaining weight while actively trying not to? That feels like your body is betraying you.

Here’s what many people don’t realize: unexplained weight gain is often a symptom, not a character flaw. It can signal that something has shifted in your metabolism, your hormones, your thyroid, or other body systems. And when the cause is medical, no amount of willpower will fix it — because you’re fighting biology, not behavior.

This doesn’t mean every instance of weight gain has a medical cause. But when weight gain is truly unexplained — when it doesn’t correlate with changes in eating or activity — investigating the underlying cause isn’t just reasonable, it’s necessary.

Blood testing can reveal what’s happening beneath the surface. It can identify thyroid dysfunction, insulin resistance, hormonal imbalances, and other conditions that promote weight gain regardless of lifestyle. Finding the cause changes everything: instead of fighting harder against your body, you can address what’s actually wrong.

When Weight Gain Is a Symptom

Not all weight gain is the same. Understanding what type you’re experiencing helps determine whether investigation is warranted.

Weight gain that usually has lifestyle explanations:

• Gradual gain during periods of reduced activity
• Gain that correlates with dietary changes (even subtle ones)
• Holiday or vacation weight that accumulates predictably
• Age-related changes that develop slowly over years
• Weight gain during major life transitions (new job, moving, relationship changes)
• Gain that follows a period of intentional restriction (rebound effect)
• Weight gain after quitting smoking (metabolic rate temporarily decreases)
• Gain associated with reduced daily walking or movement

Weight gain that suggests a medical cause:

• Rapid gain over weeks or months without behavior changes
• Gain despite consistent or increased exercise
• Gain despite eating less than usual
• Gain accompanied by other symptoms (fatigue, cold intolerance, mood changes, hair loss)
• Gain that defies caloric math — you’re in a deficit but still gaining
• Gain concentrated in specific areas (abdomen, face, upper back)
• Gain accompanied by swelling in legs, ankles, or face
• Gain that started after beginning a new medication
• Gain accompanied by menstrual irregularities
• Gain with significant fatigue or energy changes
• Weight gain with increased thirst and urination
• Gain accompanied by skin changes (dry skin, acne, dark patches)

If your weight gain falls into the second category, something is likely happening beyond calories in versus calories out. Your body’s regulatory systems may be malfunctioning — and blood tests can help identify where.

The importance of timeline:

When did the weight gain start? What else was happening at that time? Did you start a new medication? Experience a major stressor? Notice other symptoms? The timeline often provides crucial diagnostic clues.

Weight gain that began gradually over years has different implications than weight gain of 20 pounds in three months. Rapid changes suggest acute causes — medication effects, fluid retention, sudden hormonal shifts. Gradual changes suggest slowly developing conditions — progressive thyroid failure, worsening insulin resistance, age-related hormonal decline.

Keep a mental (or written) record of when the weight gain started and what other changes accompanied it. This information helps guide testing and interpretation.

Patterns that provide clues:

Where you gain weight matters. Different conditions produce different patterns:

• Abdominal/central weight gain: Strongly suggests insulin resistance, cortisol excess, or metabolic syndrome
• Generalized puffiness: May indicate thyroid dysfunction or fluid retention
• Face and upper back (“moon face,” “buffalo hump”): Classic pattern of cortisol excess (Cushing’s)
• Lower extremity swelling: Points toward heart, kidney, liver, or venous issues
• Weight that fluctuates dramatically day to day: Suggests fluid shifts rather than fat gain

The Metabolism Misconception

When people gain weight unexpectedly, they often blame a “slow metabolism.” This isn’t entirely wrong — but it’s incomplete and often misunderstood.

Your metabolic rate isn’t a fixed number you’re born with. It’s regulated by multiple systems, including your thyroid hormones, insulin signaling, stress hormones, sex hormones, and more. When any of these systems malfunction, your metabolism can genuinely slow — not because of bad genetics, but because of a medical condition.

What actually determines metabolic rate:

• Basal metabolic rate (BMR): The calories your body burns at complete rest — keeping your heart beating, lungs breathing, cells functioning. This accounts for 60-75% of daily calorie expenditure. BMR is influenced by body size, body composition (muscle vs. fat), age, sex, and hormonal status.
• Thermic effect of food: Energy used to digest and process food — about 10% of calories consumed. Protein requires more energy to digest than carbohydrates or fat.
• Physical activity: Both intentional exercise and non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT) — walking, fidgeting, standing, daily movement. This is the most variable component and can differ by hundreds of calories between individuals.
• Adaptive thermogenesis: Your body’s ability to adjust energy expenditure in response to environmental factors like temperature, overfeeding, or underfeeding.

What can lower metabolic rate:

• Thyroid dysfunction: Thyroid hormones directly regulate metabolic rate at the cellular level. Low levels mean lower metabolism — potentially 15-20% lower in significant hypothyroidism.
• Loss of muscle mass: Muscle is metabolically active tissue, burning calories even at rest. Less muscle means fewer calories burned. This is one reason age-related weight gain occurs — muscle mass naturally declines.
• Aging: Metabolic rate naturally declines approximately 1-2% per decade after age 20, partly due to muscle loss and hormonal changes.
• Chronic calorie restriction: Severe or prolonged dieting can lower metabolic rate as the body adapts to conserve energy. This “metabolic adaptation” can persist even after dieting ends.
• Hormonal imbalances: Cortisol, sex hormones (testosterone, estrogen), and growth hormone all influence metabolism. Imbalances in any can affect energy expenditure.
• Sleep deprivation: Poor sleep affects hormones that regulate metabolism and appetite, including leptin, ghrelin, and cortisol.
• Chronic inflammation: Ongoing inflammation can affect metabolic function and promote fat storage.

The key insight: if a medical condition is affecting your metabolism, the condition needs to be treated. Eating less and exercising more won’t fix a thyroid that isn’t producing enough hormone. It won’t overcome severe insulin resistance. It won’t correct a cortisol imbalance. This is why identifying the cause matters — it’s not about finding an excuse, it’s about finding the right solution.

The myth of the “damaged metabolism”:

Some people worry that dieting has permanently “damaged” their metabolism. While severe calorie restriction can cause metabolic adaptation, this is generally reversible. However, the metabolic slowdown from medical conditions like hypothyroidism is not something you can “fix” with willpower — it requires treating the underlying condition.

Thyroid Dysfunction: The Classic Culprit

Hypothyroidism — an underactive thyroid — is one of the most common medical causes of unexplained weight gain, affecting approximately 5% of adults, with many more cases undiagnosed. The thyroid gland produces hormones that regulate metabolism throughout your body. When thyroid hormone production drops, everything slows down.

How the thyroid controls metabolism:

The thyroid gland, located in the front of your neck, produces two main hormones: thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3). T4 is produced in larger quantities but is relatively inactive — it serves as a reservoir that can be converted to T3 as needed. T3 is the active hormone that actually affects cells.

The production of these hormones is controlled by the pituitary gland, which releases thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH). When thyroid hormone levels are low, TSH rises to stimulate more production. When levels are adequate, TSH decreases. This feedback loop normally keeps thyroid hormones in balance.

Thyroid hormones affect virtually every cell in your body. They regulate:

• How quickly cells use energy (oxygen consumption)
• How efficiently mitochondria produce ATP (cellular energy)
• How the body generates heat (thermogenesis)
• Heart rate and cardiac output
• Gut motility and digestion
• Protein synthesis and breakdown
• Cholesterol metabolism
• Brain function and mood

When thyroid hormone levels drop, all of these processes slow down — explaining the wide range of symptoms in hypothyroidism.

How hypothyroidism causes weight gain:

• Reduced basal metabolic rate: Your body burns fewer calories at rest — sometimes 15-20% fewer. For someone who normally burns 1,800 calories at rest, that’s 270-360 fewer calories per day, which adds up quickly.
• Decreased thermogenesis: Less heat production means less energy expenditure. This also explains the cold intolerance common in hypothyroidism.
• Fluid retention: Hypothyroidism causes accumulation of glycosaminoglycans — substances that attract water into tissues, creating a characteristic puffiness (myxedema). This can account for several pounds of weight that isn’t fat.
• Reduced physical activity: Fatigue, muscle weakness, and low energy lead to less movement — both intentional exercise and everyday activity like walking and fidgeting.
• Changes in body composition: Hypothyroidism may promote fat storage and reduce muscle protein synthesis, shifting the ratio toward more fat and less metabolically active muscle.
• Altered gut motility: Slowed digestion (causing constipation) can affect nutrient absorption and contribute to bloating and discomfort.
• Increased cholesterol: Hypothyroidism impairs cholesterol clearance, raising LDL — this doesn’t cause weight gain directly but indicates metabolic dysfunction.

Other symptoms that accompany thyroid-related weight gain:

• Fatigue and low energy — often profound, not relieved by sleep
• Feeling cold when others are comfortable (cold intolerance)
• Constipation
• Dry skin and hair
• Hair loss or thinning, including the characteristic loss of the outer third of eyebrows
• Brain fog, difficulty concentrating, and memory problems
• Depression, low mood, or emotional flatness
• Muscle weakness, aches, stiffness, or cramps
• Slower heart rate (bradycardia)
• Hoarse voice
• Menstrual irregularities — often heavy or prolonged periods
• Elevated cholesterol, especially LDL
• Puffy face, especially around the eyes
• Slowed reflexes

If you’re gaining weight AND experiencing several of these symptoms, thyroid dysfunction moves to the top of the suspect list. The more symptoms you have, the higher the likelihood of a thyroid problem.

Hashimoto’s thyroiditis — the most common cause:

Hashimoto’s thyroiditis is an autoimmune condition in which the immune system gradually destroys the thyroid gland. It’s the most common cause of hypothyroidism in developed countries and is 5-10 times more common in women than men.

In Hashimoto’s, immune cells attack thyroid tissue, causing chronic inflammation that progressively impairs the gland’s ability to produce hormones. This process typically occurs over years — thyroid function may be normal initially, then progress through subclinical hypothyroidism to overt hypothyroidism.

What makes Hashimoto’s important to identify:

• It’s progressive — thyroid function typically declines over time, so early detection allows monitoring and timely intervention
• Antibodies (TPO and thyroglobulin antibodies) can be detected years before TSH becomes abnormal
• It’s associated with other autoimmune conditions (type 1 diabetes, celiac disease, vitiligo, rheumatoid arthritis)
• Family history significantly increases risk — if a first-degree relative has thyroid disease, your risk is elevated
• Lifestyle factors may influence progression — some evidence suggests that selenium, vitamin D status, and gut health can affect autoimmune thyroid activity

The subclinical hypothyroidism question:

Some people have “subclinical” hypothyroidism — TSH is elevated above the reference range but still below clearly abnormal levels, with normal T4. Whether this causes symptoms, including weight gain, is debated in medicine.

The evidence is mixed: some studies show minimal symptoms in subclinical hypothyroidism, while others show that many people report improvement when treated. Several factors may explain this discrepancy:

• The “normal” TSH range is statistically derived and may be too wide for individual optimization
• What’s normal for you may differ from population averages
• Some people are more sensitive to small changes in thyroid function than others
• Subclinical hypothyroidism in younger people may have different implications than in older adults

If you have subclinical hypothyroidism with symptoms, it’s worth discussing treatment options with your healthcare provider. Tracking trends over time (is your TSH rising?) and correlating with symptoms provides important context for decision-making.

What to test:

TSH (thyroid-stimulating hormone) is the primary screening test. When the thyroid is underactive, TSH rises as the pituitary gland tries to stimulate more hormone production. Elevated TSH is the most sensitive early marker of thyroid dysfunction.

Free T4 measures the actual thyroid hormone circulating in your blood that’s available to tissues. This confirms whether the thyroid is producing adequate hormone. In overt hypothyroidism, free T4 will be low; in subclinical hypothyroidism, free T4 is still normal despite elevated TSH.

Free T3 measures the active form of thyroid hormone. Some people have conversion issues — adequate T4 but low T3 — that TSH and T4 alone would miss. This is particularly relevant in people with persistent symptoms despite “normal” TSH and T4. Factors that can impair T4-to-T3 conversion include chronic stress, inflammation, selenium deficiency, and certain medications.

TPO antibodies (thyroid peroxidase antibodies) are present in approximately 90% of Hashimoto’s cases. Thyroglobulin antibodies can also indicate autoimmune thyroid disease. You can have positive antibodies years before TSH becomes abnormal — catching the autoimmune process early allows monitoring and potentially earlier intervention.

Reverse T3 is sometimes tested in complex cases. It’s an inactive form of T3 that can accumulate when the body is under stress, illness, or calorie restriction. Elevated reverse T3 with low-normal T3 can indicate a conversion problem, though the clinical significance is debated.

Insulin Resistance: The Hidden Driver

Insulin resistance may be the most underdiagnosed cause of unexplained weight gain. It affects an estimated 40% or more of adults in developed countries, yet most don’t know they have it — because standard checkups don’t test for it directly.

Understanding insulin’s role:

Insulin is a hormone released by the pancreas in response to eating, particularly carbohydrates. Its primary job is to move glucose from your blood into cells for energy or storage. But insulin does much more:

• Promotes glucose uptake into muscle and fat cells
• Stimulates glycogen synthesis (glucose storage) in liver and muscle
• Promotes fat storage (lipogenesis)
• Inhibits fat breakdown (lipolysis)
• Promotes protein synthesis
• Affects appetite regulation through interactions with other hormones

In a healthy state, cells respond readily to insulin’s signal. When you eat, blood sugar rises, insulin is released, glucose enters cells efficiently, blood sugar drops back to normal, and insulin levels return to baseline between meals. This cycle keeps energy flowing appropriately.

What happens in insulin resistance:

When cells become resistant to insulin’s signal, glucose doesn’t enter cells as efficiently. Blood sugar rises. The pancreas responds by producing more insulin to overcome the resistance — essentially “shouting louder” to be heard. This creates chronically elevated insulin levels (hyperinsulinemia).

For a while, this compensation works — blood sugar stays relatively normal because insulin is high enough to force glucose into cells. But this comes at a cost: the metabolic effects of high insulin are significant.

How insulin resistance causes weight gain:

• Promotes fat storage: Insulin is fundamentally a storage hormone. High insulin tells your body to store energy as fat, particularly in abdominal adipose tissue. When insulin is chronically elevated, your body is constantly in “storage mode.”
• Blocks fat burning: Elevated insulin inhibits lipolysis — the breakdown of stored fat for energy. Even if you’re eating less, your body can’t efficiently access its fat stores for fuel when insulin is high. This is why calorie restriction often fails in insulin resistance.
• Drives hunger and cravings: Insulin fluctuations trigger hunger, especially for carbohydrates. The cycle becomes: eat carbs → blood sugar spikes → insulin surges → blood sugar crashes (reactive hypoglycemia) → hunger and cravings → eat more carbs. This makes appetite control extremely difficult.
• Promotes visceral fat accumulation: Insulin resistance particularly promotes accumulation of visceral fat — the metabolically dangerous fat surrounding abdominal organs. Visceral fat is more inflammatory than subcutaneous fat and worsens metabolic dysfunction.
• Reduces muscle glucose uptake: When muscles are insulin resistant, less glucose is available for muscle energy, potentially affecting exercise capacity and recovery.
• Affects leptin signaling: Leptin is your satiety hormone, released by fat cells to signal fullness. Insulin resistance often accompanies leptin resistance, meaning the brain doesn’t “hear” the fullness signal properly. You can have plenty of leptin but still feel hungry.
• Promotes inflammation: Insulin resistance is associated with chronic low-grade inflammation, which itself promotes further insulin resistance and weight gain.

The vicious cycle:

This creates a self-reinforcing cycle that’s difficult to break: insulin resistance promotes weight gain, particularly visceral fat. Visceral fat produces inflammatory signals (adipokines) that worsen insulin resistance. Worse insulin resistance means higher insulin levels, promoting more fat storage. The cycle accelerates.

Breaking this cycle requires addressing the insulin resistance directly — simply eating less often fails because high insulin blocks fat burning and drives hunger.

Signs that suggest insulin resistance:

• Weight concentrated around the abdomen (apple shape, central obesity)
• Waist circumference greater than 35 inches (women) or 40 inches (men)
• Difficulty losing weight despite calorie restriction
• Hunger soon after eating, especially after carbohydrate-rich meals
• Energy crashes, particularly in mid-afternoon
• Strong cravings for sweets and carbohydrates
• Feeling better after eating (blood sugar was low)
• Skin tags, especially on neck, armpits, or groin
• Dark patches of skin (acanthosis nigricans), often on neck, armpits, or skin folds
• Fatigue, especially after meals (post-meal energy crash)
• Brain fog or difficulty concentrating
• Family history of type 2 diabetes
• Personal history of gestational diabetes
• Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) — present in 70-80% of cases
• High blood pressure
• Elevated triglycerides and/or low HDL cholesterol

What to test:

Fasting insulin is the most direct measure of insulin resistance, yet standard checkups rarely include it — they check glucose instead. This is a significant blind spot. Insulin levels rise years before glucose becomes abnormal. By the time fasting glucose is elevated, insulin resistance has been present for a long time, and significant metabolic damage may have occurred.

Fasting glucose is routinely tested but is a late marker. Glucose stays normal for years while insulin climbs higher and higher to compensate. A “normal” fasting glucose doesn’t rule out insulin resistance.

HbA1c reflects average blood sugar over 2-3 months. It’s useful for tracking blood sugar control but, like fasting glucose, is a late marker that may be normal despite significant insulin resistance.

Triglycerides and HDL cholesterol provide important indirect clues. Insulin resistance typically raises triglycerides and lowers HDL. The triglyceride-to-HDL ratio is a useful surrogate marker for insulin resistance — a ratio above 2.0 (or 3.0 using different units) suggests insulin resistance even if individual values are within the “normal” range.

HOMA-IR calculation: If you have both fasting insulin and fasting glucose, your healthcare provider can calculate HOMA-IR (Homeostatic Model Assessment of Insulin Resistance) — a validated formula that estimates insulin resistance. Higher values indicate greater insulin resistance.

The prediabetes connection:

Insulin resistance is the precursor to prediabetes and type 2 diabetes. The progression typically follows this pattern:

1. Insulin resistance develops (often undetected for years)
2. Fasting insulin rises as the pancreas compensates
3. Blood sugar remains normal because insulin compensation is successful
4. Over time, the pancreas becomes exhausted or can’t keep up
5. Blood sugar begins to rise — first to prediabetic range, then diabetic range

Catching insulin resistance early — while glucose is still normal — allows intervention before this progression. At this stage, lifestyle changes (dietary modifications, exercise, weight loss) are often highly effective and may prevent ever developing diabetes.

PCOS: When Hormones Conspire Against Weight

Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is one of the most common hormonal disorders in women of reproductive age, affecting approximately 8-13% of women worldwide, with up to 70% remaining undiagnosed. Weight gain and difficulty losing weight are hallmark features — and often the most frustrating aspects of the condition.

Understanding PCOS:

PCOS is a syndrome, meaning it involves multiple features that cluster together rather than a single abnormality. The three main diagnostic criteria (Rotterdam criteria) are:

• Irregular or absent ovulation/periods (oligo-ovulation or anovulation)
• Elevated androgens (male hormones) — either by blood test or clinical signs like hirsutism and acne
• Polycystic ovaries on ultrasound (multiple small follicles in characteristic pattern)

Diagnosis typically requires two of these three criteria, after ruling out other conditions that can cause similar symptoms (thyroid disorders, congenital adrenal hyperplasia, androgen-secreting tumors, hyperprolactinemia).

How PCOS causes weight gain:

• Insulin resistance: Present in 70-80% of women with PCOS, regardless of weight. This is the central metabolic feature and drives many PCOS symptoms, including weight gain. The mechanisms are the same as described in the insulin resistance section — fat storage promotion, fat burning inhibition, hunger and cravings.
• Elevated androgens: Higher testosterone and related hormones affect fat distribution (promoting central adiposity), may influence appetite and eating behavior, and affect metabolism. Androgens can also promote muscle development, but the net effect in PCOS is often weight gain.
• Hormonal appetite disruption: PCOS involves imbalances in multiple hormones that regulate appetite, including leptin (satiety), ghrelin (hunger), and cholecystokinin. Many women with PCOS report feeling hungry despite eating enough.
• Chronic low-grade inflammation: PCOS is associated with elevated inflammatory markers. Chronic inflammation promotes weight gain, worsens insulin resistance, and may affect appetite regulation.
• Reduced metabolic rate: Some research suggests women with PCOS have lower basal metabolic rates compared to women without PCOS of the same weight and body composition. This means burning fewer calories at rest.
• Sleep disturbances: PCOS is associated with higher rates of sleep apnea and poor sleep quality, which affect metabolic hormones and weight regulation.

The bidirectional relationship:

PCOS and weight have a complex, bidirectional relationship. PCOS promotes weight gain through the mechanisms above, and excess weight worsens PCOS symptoms by increasing insulin resistance and inflammation, which further elevates androgens. This creates a challenging cycle.

However, it’s crucial to understand that PCOS can occur in women who are not overweight — approximately 20-30% of women with PCOS are lean. PCOS is not caused by excess weight, even though weight significantly affects its severity and symptom expression. Lean women with PCOS often have less insulin resistance but can still experience significant symptoms.

Other signs of PCOS:

• Irregular periods — cycles longer than 35 days, fewer than 8 periods per year, or absent periods (amenorrhea)
• Excess facial or body hair (hirsutism) — typically on face, chest, abdomen, back, following male-pattern distribution
• Acne — especially along the jawline and lower face, often severe and persistent into adulthood
• Thinning hair on the head (androgenic alopecia) — male-pattern hair loss
• Difficulty getting pregnant (infertility due to irregular or absent ovulation)
• Skin tags, especially on neck and armpits
• Dark, velvety skin patches (acanthosis nigricans) — neck, armpits, under breasts, groin
• Mood changes — higher rates of depression and anxiety
• Sleep problems — increased risk of sleep apnea

What to test:

Total testosterone and free testosterone are often elevated in PCOS. Free testosterone is frequently elevated even when total testosterone is normal because SHBG (which binds testosterone) is typically low.

DHEA-S — an androgen precursor from the adrenal glands — may be mildly elevated. Significantly elevated DHEA-S suggests adrenal contribution to androgen excess.

SHBG (sex hormone-binding globulin) is often low in PCOS due to insulin resistance (insulin suppresses SHBG production). Low SHBG increases the fraction of testosterone that’s free and active.

LH (luteinizing hormone) and FSH (follicle-stimulating hormone) can be informative. LH is often elevated relative to FSH in PCOS — an LH:FSH ratio greater than 2:1 or 3:1 is suggestive, though not diagnostic.

Anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) is often elevated in PCOS, reflecting the increased number of small follicles in the ovaries. Very high AMH can support the diagnosis.

Metabolic markers are crucial given the strong insulin resistance component: fasting insulin, fasting glucose, HbA1c, triglycerides, and HDL. These should be part of PCOS evaluation and monitoring.

Different phenotypes of PCOS:

PCOS isn’t a single condition — it has different phenotypes with different underlying drivers and implications:

• Insulin-resistant PCOS (Type A): The most common type. Insulin resistance drives excess androgen production from the ovaries. Responds well to insulin-sensitizing approaches.
• Inflammatory PCOS: Chronic inflammation triggers androgen production and ovulatory dysfunction. May have elevated inflammatory markers (hs-CRP) without severe insulin resistance.
• Adrenal PCOS: Elevated DHEA-S with normal ovarian androgens suggests adrenal contribution. May respond differently to treatment.
• Lean PCOS: Normal weight with PCOS features. May have less insulin resistance but can still have significant symptoms.
• Post-pill PCOS: Temporary androgen elevation and cycle irregularity after stopping hormonal contraception. Often resolves within months but can unmask underlying PCOS.

Identifying the phenotype helps guide treatment — insulin-resistant PCOS responds well to lifestyle changes targeting insulin sensitivity and medications like metformin, while other types may need different approaches.

Cortisol and Stress: The Belly Fat Hormone

Cortisol is your primary stress hormone, produced by the adrenal glands in response to signals from the hypothalamus and pituitary gland (the HPA axis). In acute situations, cortisol is essential for survival — it mobilizes energy, sharpens focus, and prepares your body to handle threats. But chronically elevated cortisol — from ongoing stress, sleep deprivation, or medical conditions — promotes weight gain in characteristic patterns.

The normal cortisol pattern:

In a healthy state, cortisol follows a circadian rhythm: it peaks in the early morning (helping you wake up and mobilize energy for the day), declines through the afternoon, and reaches its lowest point at night (allowing restful sleep). This rhythm can become disrupted by:

• Chronic psychological stress
• Poor sleep or sleep deprivation
• Shift work or irregular schedules
• Chronic illness or pain
• Certain medications
• Medical conditions affecting the adrenal or pituitary glands

How cortisol causes weight gain:

• Promotes visceral fat storage: Cortisol specifically increases accumulation of abdominal and visceral fat. Fat cells in the abdominal region have four times more cortisol receptors than fat cells elsewhere, making this area particularly sensitive to cortisol’s effects. This explains why chronic stress leads to belly fat.
• Increases appetite: Cortisol stimulates appetite, particularly for high-calorie, palatable foods rich in sugar and fat. This is the biological basis for “stress eating” — your body is trying to replenish the energy it thinks you’re using to deal with the stressor.
• Promotes insulin resistance: Chronic cortisol elevation impairs insulin signaling, contributing to metabolic dysfunction and compounding weight gain through insulin-resistance mechanisms.
• Breaks down muscle: Cortisol is catabolic to muscle tissue — it promotes muscle protein breakdown to release amino acids for energy. Less muscle means lower metabolic rate and reduced calorie burning at rest.
• Disrupts sleep: Elevated evening cortisol impairs sleep quality and duration. Poor sleep further elevates cortisol the next day, creating a vicious cycle. Sleep deprivation also affects other metabolic hormones (leptin, ghrelin) that influence appetite and weight.
• Affects thyroid function: Chronic stress can suppress TSH and impair conversion of T4 to active T3, effectively slowing metabolism.
• Promotes fluid retention: Cortisol has mineralocorticoid effects, promoting sodium and water retention.

Cushing’s syndrome — the extreme case:

Cushing’s syndrome occurs when cortisol levels are chronically and significantly elevated. This can result from:

• A pituitary tumor producing excess ACTH (Cushing’s disease)
• An adrenal tumor producing excess cortisol
• Ectopic ACTH production by other tumors
• Long-term use of corticosteroid medications (prednisone, dexamethasone) — the most common cause

Signs of Cushing’s syndrome include:

• Dramatic weight gain with characteristic distribution — face (moon face), upper back (buffalo hump), and abdomen
• Arms and legs may remain relatively thin (proximal muscle wasting)
• Purple or red stretch marks (striae) on abdomen, thighs, breasts, arms
• Thin, fragile skin that bruises easily
• Slow healing of wounds and cuts
• Muscle weakness, particularly in thighs and upper arms
• High blood pressure
• High blood sugar / diabetes
• Bone loss (osteoporosis) and fractures
• Mood changes, depression, anxiety, irritability
• Irregular periods in women
• Decreased libido

Cushing’s syndrome is relatively rare but important to identify because it requires specific treatment. If you have multiple characteristic features, testing should be pursued.

More common: chronic stress and cortisol dysregulation:

You don’t need Cushing’s syndrome for cortisol to contribute to weight gain. Chronic stress and cortisol dysregulation are far more common and can significantly impact weight, even when cortisol levels aren’t high enough to meet Cushing’s diagnostic criteria.

Contributors to chronic cortisol elevation and HPA axis dysregulation:

• Chronic psychological stress — work pressure, financial worries, relationship problems, caregiving burden
• Sleep deprivation or poor sleep quality
• Shift work or irregular sleep schedules
• Overtraining — excessive exercise without adequate recovery is a physical stressor
• Chronic inflammation from any cause
• Chronic pain
• Excessive caffeine intake, especially later in the day
• Untreated sleep apnea

What to test:

Cortisol can be measured in blood, though interpretation requires context. Because cortisol naturally fluctuates throughout the day, timing matters significantly. Morning cortisol (typically drawn between 7-9 AM) should be at its peak — very low morning cortisol may indicate adrenal insufficiency, while very high levels raise concern for Cushing’s.

For suspected Cushing’s syndrome, additional testing may include:

• 24-hour urinary free cortisol — measures total cortisol production over a full day
• Late-night salivary cortisol — cortisol should be low at night; elevated late-night cortisol strongly suggests Cushing’s
• Dexamethasone suppression test — normally, taking dexamethasone suppresses cortisol production; failure to suppress suggests Cushing’s

For stress-related cortisol issues (not Cushing’s), a four-point salivary cortisol test measuring cortisol at waking, noon, evening, and bedtime can reveal whether the normal daily rhythm is disrupted.

Low Testosterone: Not Just a Male Problem

Testosterone plays a metabolic role in both men and women. When levels drop below optimal, body composition shifts toward more fat and less muscle — and weight often increases as a result.

Testosterone in men:

Testosterone is the primary male sex hormone, produced mainly in the testes. It naturally declines with age — approximately 1-2% per year after age 30. However, there’s significant individual variation, and some men experience more rapid or pronounced decline that affects health and quality of life.

Low testosterone (hypogonadism) affects body composition and weight through several mechanisms:

• Decreased muscle mass: Testosterone is anabolic — it promotes muscle protein synthesis. Low levels lead to gradual muscle loss (sarcopenia), reducing the metabolically active tissue that burns calories even at rest.
• Increased body fat: As muscle decreases, the balance shifts toward fat accumulation, particularly in the abdominal region.
• Reduced metabolic rate: Less muscle means fewer calories burned at rest. This can amount to a significant caloric difference over time.
• Fatigue and reduced motivation: Low testosterone causes fatigue that can decrease physical activity and exercise.
• Insulin resistance: Low testosterone is associated with worse insulin sensitivity, compounding metabolic dysfunction.
• Reduced fat oxidation: Some evidence suggests testosterone affects the body’s ability to burn fat for fuel.

Other symptoms of low testosterone in men:

• Decreased libido (sex drive)
• Erectile dysfunction
• Depressed mood, irritability, or emotional flatness
• Reduced strength and physical performance
• Fatigue and low energy despite adequate sleep
• Difficulty concentrating and memory problems
• Decreased bone density
• Sleep disturbances
• Breast enlargement (gynecomastia)
• Reduced body hair
• Hot flashes (in severe cases)

Testosterone in women:

Women produce testosterone too — in the ovaries and adrenal glands — just in smaller amounts (roughly 10% of male levels). Testosterone in women affects muscle mass and strength, bone density, libido and sexual function, energy levels, mood and wellbeing, and cognitive function.

Low testosterone in women (which can occur with aging, after menopause, after oophorectomy, or from adrenal insufficiency) can contribute to reduced muscle mass and lower metabolic rate, fatigue and low energy, decreased libido, and depressed mood.

However, in PCOS, testosterone is typically elevated rather than low — so context matters greatly in interpreting testosterone levels in women.

The testosterone-obesity bidirectional relationship:

In men, there’s a well-established bidirectional relationship between testosterone and body fat. Low testosterone promotes fat gain (especially visceral fat), and excess fat further lowers testosterone. This occurs because adipose tissue contains aromatase — an enzyme that converts testosterone to estrogen. More fat means more aromatase activity, more testosterone conversion, and lower testosterone levels. This creates a self-reinforcing cycle that’s difficult to break.

What to test:

Total testosterone measures all testosterone in the blood. Testing should be done in the morning (before 10 AM) when levels are highest. Two low readings on separate occasions are typically required for diagnosis of hypogonadism.

Free testosterone measures the testosterone not bound to proteins and available to tissues. This is particularly important because total testosterone can appear normal while free testosterone is low (if SHBG is elevated).

SHBG affects how much testosterone is available to tissues. High SHBG (from aging, liver disease, hyperthyroidism) means less free testosterone even if total testosterone appears normal. Low SHBG (from obesity, insulin resistance, hypothyroidism) increases free testosterone relative to total.

LH and FSH help determine the cause of low testosterone. If testosterone is low and LH/FSH are high, the problem is in the testes (primary hypogonadism — the testes aren’t responding to stimulation). If testosterone is low and LH/FSH are low or inappropriately normal, the problem is in the pituitary or hypothalamus (secondary hypogonadism — inadequate stimulation of the testes).

Prolactin should be checked because elevated prolactin can suppress testosterone production. This might indicate a pituitary issue requiring further investigation.

Fluid Retention: Weight That Isn’t Fat

Sometimes weight gain isn’t fat at all — it’s fluid. Several conditions cause the body to retain water, leading to rapid weight changes that have nothing to do with calories, diet, or body composition changes.

How to recognize fluid retention:

• Rapid changes — several pounds in just days (too fast to be fat gain)
• Swelling (edema) in ankles, legs, hands, or face
• Pitting edema — when you press on swollen skin, an indentation remains for several seconds
• Puffiness in face, especially around the eyes in the morning
• Weight that fluctuates dramatically from day to day
• Rings feel tight, shoes don’t fit, watch band feels snug
• Clothing fits tightly in some areas but not others
• Shortness of breath, especially when lying flat (if fluid is accumulating in or around lungs)
• Abdominal distension (if fluid is accumulating in abdomen)

Conditions causing fluid retention:

• Hypothyroidism: Causes a specific type of fluid retention called myxedema — accumulation of glycosaminoglycans that attract water into tissues, causing a generalized, non-pitting puffiness
• Heart failure: The heart can’t pump efficiently, causing fluid to back up in the venous system and leak into tissues. Typically affects the lower extremities (ankles, legs) and worsens throughout the day.
• Kidney disease: Impaired ability to excrete sodium and water leads to generalized fluid retention. May also involve protein loss in urine (nephrotic syndrome) causing even more edema.
• Liver disease: Reduced albumin production (albumin helps keep fluid in blood vessels) and portal hypertension cause fluid accumulation, often in the abdomen (ascites) and legs.
• Venous insufficiency: Poor circulation in leg veins allows fluid to pool in the lower extremities. Common and often underdiagnosed.
• Lymphedema: Impaired lymphatic drainage causes localized, often asymmetric swelling.
• Medications: Common culprits include calcium channel blockers (especially amlodipine), NSAIDs, corticosteroids, some diabetes medications (thiazolidinediones), and hormonal medications.
• Hormonal fluctuations: Premenstrual fluid retention is common; some women gain several pounds in the days before their period. Perimenopause can also cause fluid shifts.
• High sodium intake: Excess salt causes temporary water retention as the body maintains sodium-water balance.
• Prolonged sitting or standing: Gravity causes fluid to pool in lower extremities.

What to test:

If significant fluid retention is suspected, testing should assess the organs that regulate fluid balance:

• Creatinine and eGFR for kidney function
• BUN (blood urea nitrogen) — another kidney function marker
• ALT, AST, and albumin for liver function
• TSH for thyroid function
• BNP or NT-proBNP — natriuretic peptides elevated in heart failure
• Urinalysis — checking for protein (proteinuria indicates kidney damage)

Medications That Cause Weight Gain

Many commonly prescribed medications can cause weight gain as a side effect — sometimes significantly. If your weight gain coincided with starting a new medication, this connection is worth exploring with your healthcare provider.

Medications known to cause weight gain:

Psychiatric medications:

• Antidepressants: SSRIs can cause weight gain (paroxetine is often worst), SNRIs (venlafaxine, duloxetine), tricyclics (amitriptyline, nortriptyline), mirtazapine (significant — can increase appetite dramatically), MAOIs
• Antipsychotics: Olanzapine and clozapine cause the most weight gain (sometimes 20+ pounds), quetiapine, risperidone — these medications can also cause metabolic syndrome and diabetes
• Mood stabilizers: Lithium (common), valproate/valproic acid (significant), carbamazepine
• Anti-anxiety: Some benzodiazepines may contribute

Diabetes medications:

• Insulin: Promotes fat storage; weight gain is common especially with intensive insulin therapy
• Sulfonylureas: Glipizide, glyburide, glimepiride — stimulate insulin secretion
• Thiazolidinediones: Pioglitazone — promotes fat storage, causes fluid retention
• Note: Some newer diabetes medications are weight-neutral or promote weight loss: metformin (slight weight loss or neutral), GLP-1 agonists like semaglutide and liraglutide (significant weight loss), SGLT2 inhibitors (modest weight loss)

Corticosteroids:

• Prednisone, dexamethasone, methylprednisolone, hydrocortisone
• Weight gain risk increases with higher doses and longer duration
• Mechanism: increased appetite, fat redistribution, fluid retention, insulin resistance

Blood pressure and heart medications:

• Some beta-blockers: atenolol, metoprolol (older agents more problematic)
• Newer beta-blockers (carvedilol, nebivolol) may be more weight-neutral

Anti-seizure medications:

• Gabapentin and pregabalin — significant weight gain potential
• Valproate
• Carbamazepine (mild)
• Note: Some anti-seizure medications are weight-neutral (lamotrigine) or cause weight loss (topiramate, zonisamide)

Hormonal medications:

• Some hormonal contraceptives — effects are variable and individual
• Medroxyprogesterone (Depo-Provera) — associated with weight gain
• Hormone replacement therapy — variable effects

Other medications:

• Some antihistamines (first-generation like diphenhydramine) — can increase appetite
• Some migraine preventives (amitriptyline, valproate)

What to do if medication is suspected:

Don’t stop necessary medications without discussing with your prescriber. But do have a conversation that includes: whether the weight gain is likely related to the medication, whether alternative medications with less weight impact exist within the same class, whether dose adjustment might help, and strategies to manage weight while continuing necessary treatment.

Other Conditions to Consider

Sleep Apnea

Obstructive sleep apnea and weight gain have a complex bidirectional relationship. Excess weight increases sleep apnea risk because fat deposits around the upper airway can obstruct breathing during sleep. But sleep apnea also promotes weight gain through multiple mechanisms:

• Disrupted sleep increases ghrelin (the hunger hormone) and decreases leptin (the satiety hormone), promoting overeating
• Sleep deprivation promotes insulin resistance
• Intermittent hypoxia (low oxygen) during apneas increases cortisol
• Chronic fatigue reduces physical activity and exercise tolerance
• Sleep apnea is associated with increased inflammation

Signs of sleep apnea: snoring (often loud), witnessed breathing pauses during sleep, waking gasping or choking, morning headaches, excessive daytime sleepiness despite adequate sleep time, difficulty concentrating, irritability. If you’re gaining weight and have these symptoms, evaluation for sleep apnea is warranted.

Menopause and Perimenopause

The hormonal shifts of menopause — declining estrogen and progesterone — commonly lead to weight redistribution and gain. This is a physiological process, not imagined:

• Declining estrogen promotes abdominal fat storage — the shift from gynoid (hip/thigh) to android (abdominal) fat distribution
• Loss of estrogen’s metabolic protective effects
• Age-related muscle loss (sarcopenia) accelerates
• Sleep disruption from hot flashes and night sweats affects metabolic hormones
• Changes in gut microbiome may affect metabolism

The average weight gain during the menopausal transition is 5-8 pounds, though individual variation is significant. The shift toward abdominal fat increases metabolic and cardiovascular risk even if total weight gain is modest.

Depression

Depression can cause weight gain through multiple pathways:

• Changes in appetite — often increased appetite and cravings for comfort foods
• Reduced physical activity and motivation to exercise
• Disrupted sleep affecting metabolic hormones
• Effects on cortisol and other stress hormones
• Some antidepressant medications contribute to weight gain (as discussed above)

Weight gain can also worsen depression, creating a cycle. Addressing the depression itself — through therapy, medication (choosing weight-neutral options when possible), lifestyle changes, or combination approaches — is essential for overall health, including weight management.

Chronic Pain

Living with chronic pain contributes to weight gain through reduced physical activity, disrupted sleep, depression and stress, pain medications (some opioids and related medications), and comfort eating. Managing pain effectively, while challenging, can help address associated weight issues.

The Testing Strategy

When weight gain is unexplained, comprehensive testing provides answers that guessing cannot. Here’s a logical, thorough approach based on the conditions most likely to cause unexplained weight gain.

Core tests for unexplained weight gain:

Thyroid panel (essential for everyone):

• TSH — primary screening test
• Free T4 — confirms thyroid hormone production
• Free T3 — measures active hormone
• TPO antibodies — identifies autoimmune thyroid disease

Metabolic markers (essential for everyone):

• Fasting insulin — direct measure of insulin resistance
• Fasting glucose
• HbA1c — average blood sugar over 2-3 months
• Triglycerides
• HDL cholesterol
• LDL cholesterol

Hormones (based on symptoms and demographics):

• Cortisol (morning) — if stress-related weight gain or Cushing’s features suspected
• For men: Total testosterone, free testosterone
• For women with irregular periods or PCOS signs: Total testosterone, free testosterone, DHEA-S, LH, FSH
• SHBG — affects free hormone levels

General health markers:

• Creatinine / eGFR — kidney function
• ALT, AST — liver function, fatty liver screening
• Complete blood count — general health
• hs-CRP — inflammation marker
• Vitamin D — deficiency associated with metabolic dysfunction

Interpreting results:

A single abnormal marker points toward a cause. Multiple abnormal markers may indicate interconnected problems — for example, insulin resistance often coexists with thyroid dysfunction, fatty liver, lipid abnormalities, low-grade inflammation, and (in men) low testosterone. Comprehensive testing reveals the full picture rather than just one piece.

Even if results are “normal,” consider:

• Where values fall within the range — barely normal versus optimal
• Trends over time — is TSH rising? Is fasting glucose creeping up?
• Patterns across markers — triglycerides elevated + HDL low suggests insulin resistance even if individual values are within the reference range
• Clinical context — symptoms matter alongside numbers

What to Do With the Information

Finding a cause is the first step. Addressing it is what actually changes outcomes.

If thyroid dysfunction is found:

Hypothyroidism is typically treated with levothyroxine — synthetic T4 that replaces what your thyroid isn’t producing. Dosing is individualized based on TSH levels. Once thyroid hormone levels normalize (usually taking several weeks), the metabolic slowdown reverses and weight becomes much easier to manage. Some people with persistent symptoms despite normalized TSH may benefit from combination T4/T3 therapy, though this remains somewhat controversial.

If insulin resistance is found:

Lifestyle interventions are first-line and highly effective:

• Reducing refined carbohydrates and added sugars
• Increasing protein and fiber (which don’t spike insulin)
• Regular physical activity, especially strength training (muscle is the largest glucose sink)
• Modest weight loss — even 5-10% significantly improves insulin sensitivity, which then makes further weight loss easier (breaking the vicious cycle)
• Improving sleep quality
• Managing stress (cortisol worsens insulin resistance)
• Time-restricted eating or intermittent fasting may help some people by lowering average insulin levels

Some people benefit from medications like metformin, which improves insulin sensitivity. Addressing insulin resistance breaks the vicious cycle and makes weight management possible.

If PCOS is found:

Management typically involves addressing insulin resistance (the underlying driver in most cases) through lifestyle modifications and sometimes metformin, hormonal management (contraceptives) if periods are irregular or other symptoms need control, anti-androgen medications (spironolactone) if hirsutism or acne are significant concerns, and fertility treatment if pregnancy is desired. Treating the insulin resistance component of PCOS makes weight management more achievable.

If cortisol dysregulation is found:

If Cushing’s syndrome is diagnosed, treatment targets the underlying cause (tumor removal, tapering steroids, or medications that block cortisol production). For more common stress-related cortisol elevation: prioritize sleep optimization (7-9 hours, consistent schedule), stress management techniques (mindfulness, therapy), regular moderate exercise (not excessive), limiting caffeine especially after noon, and addressing underlying stressors when possible.

If low testosterone is found (in men):

Options include lifestyle optimization — weight loss, exercise (especially strength training), sleep improvement, and stress reduction can improve testosterone naturally. Testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) is an option if levels are clearly low and symptoms are present, but requires medical supervision, ongoing monitoring, and discussion of risks and benefits.

If medications are contributing:

Discuss with your prescriber: Is there an alternative medication with less weight impact? Can the dose be adjusted? Are there strategies to mitigate weight gain while continuing necessary treatment?

When Weight Gain Isn’t Medical

Not every case of weight gain has a medical cause. Sometimes the explanation is lifestyle — even when it doesn’t feel that way.

Factors that can cause weight gain without obvious lifestyle changes:

• Subtle increases in portion sizes over time
• Liquid calories — alcohol, sweetened beverages, fancy coffee drinks, smoothies
• Decreased daily movement even if formal exercise is unchanged (working from home, new desk job, less walking)
• Age-related metabolic slowdown — gradual but real
• Changes in sleep patterns affecting hunger hormones
• Eating more frequently even if meals seem “healthy”
• Underestimating calorie intake — studies consistently show people underestimate by 20-50%
• Changes in the food environment — more snacks available, larger restaurant portions
• Eating while distracted (TV, phone, computer)

If comprehensive testing returns normal results, lifestyle factors deserve honest examination. This isn’t about blame — it’s about identifying what can be changed.

However, if testing reveals abnormalities, those need to be addressed. Medical causes and lifestyle factors can coexist — someone might have insulin resistance AND be eating more than they realize. Both matter and both can be addressed.

The Bottom Line

Unexplained weight gain is frustrating precisely because it feels unexplained — because your behavior hasn’t changed but your body has. This disconnect often signals that something medical is happening.

Thyroid dysfunction slows metabolism at the cellular level. Insulin resistance drives fat storage and blocks fat burning while amplifying hunger. PCOS creates a hormonal environment that promotes weight gain. Cortisol promotes abdominal fat accumulation and breaks down metabolically active muscle. Low testosterone shifts body composition toward fat. Fluid retention adds pounds that aren’t fat at all. Medications can sabotage even the best lifestyle efforts. These are real, measurable, treatable conditions — not excuses.

Blood testing transforms “why is this happening?” into specific answers. It identifies whether your thyroid is underperforming, whether insulin resistance is driving fat storage, whether hormonal imbalances are shifting your body composition. And specific answers lead to specific solutions.

If you’re gaining weight and you don’t know why, you deserve more than “eat less and move more.” You deserve investigation into what’s actually happening — and intervention that addresses the real cause.

---

Key Takeaways

• Unexplained weight gain is often a symptom — of thyroid dysfunction, insulin resistance, hormonal imbalances, cortisol dysregulation, or other medical conditions
• Hypothyroidism affects about 5% of adults — it slows metabolism significantly (15-20%) and causes weight gain along with fatigue, cold intolerance, and other symptoms
• Insulin resistance affects 40%+ of adults — it promotes fat storage, blocks fat burning, and drives hunger, yet standard checkups rarely test fasting insulin
• PCOS affects 8-13% of women — weight gain and difficulty losing weight are hallmark features, driven largely by insulin resistance and hormonal imbalances
• Cortisol promotes visceral fat accumulation — chronic stress, poor sleep, and cortisol dysregulation make abdominal weight particularly stubborn
• Low testosterone reduces muscle mass and metabolic rate — affecting body composition in both men and women
• Fluid retention can cause rapid weight changes — sometimes several pounds in days, unrelated to actual fat gain
• Many medications cause weight gain — antidepressants, antipsychotics, steroids, some diabetes and blood pressure medications
• Comprehensive blood testing identifies the cause — thyroid panel, fasting insulin, glucose, HbA1c, lipids, and hormones reveal what’s happening
• Finding the cause enables targeted treatment — addressing the underlying condition makes weight management achievable rather than a constant struggle